Dot1q and ISL

Unanswered Question
Dec 14th, 2009
User Badges:

Hi,


May i inquire if dot1q and isl can work on the same network (i.e. switch to switch connection are ISL and my AP to switch connection is Dot1q).


Antbody here who have tried this setup. Does it work?


Thanks.

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Overall Rating: 0 (0 ratings)
Loading.
Ganesh Hariharan Mon, 12/14/2009 - 00:44
User Badges:
  • Purple, 4500 points or more
  • Community Spotlight Award,

    Member's Choice, February 2016

Trunk encapsulation work only between switch to switch on trunk port so you can run different trunk encapsulation protocol between devices in your network.


Regards

Ganesh.H

vvasisth Mon, 12/14/2009 - 01:18
User Badges:
  • Silver, 250 points or more

This will work perfectly fine, only thing that matters is both ends of the trunk link should have same protocal either ISL or Dot1q.

Your setup will work just fine


regards,

Varun

rc.castillo Mon, 12/14/2009 - 01:46
User Badges:

Hi sir,


     Do i have to create a separate vlan for the dot1q trunk connected through AP? Or i can directlty have the ap have the same vlan but different encapsulation (i.e dot1q). Because when i tried to put the ap on the same vlan but different encapsulation, it didnt work.

vvasisth Mon, 12/14/2009 - 01:49
User Badges:
  • Silver, 250 points or more

when we talk about ISL and Dot1Q we are refering to trunking which means the port can carry data for more than one vlan


but i think you want 1 vlan to move on the link wher AP is connected, if thats the case then you would need the port to be an access port rather than a trunk link.

please clarify ..


regards,

Varun

vvasisth Mon, 12/14/2009 - 01:50
User Badges:
  • Silver, 250 points or more

and if you are tranfering same vlans on ISL and dot1q it would work fine as well you wont need to create seperate vlan.


Regards,

Varun

saurabh_knl Mon, 12/14/2009 - 02:53
User Badges:

Hi,


Just have this simplified:-


1. You need trunks on both the ends if there are more than one VLAN supposed to be traversing through it.

2. ISL does not supports native vlan, by default. Thus, if you are using voice make sure it aint going in the native vlan, in a setup as yours. Have the voice packets tagged into a vlan, and have it traversed in the network.

3. The trunk encapsulation type (ISL or DOT1Q) should be same on both the ends of the trunk. However, on different trunks it can be different, and can thus coexist in the same environment.



HTH


cheers,

Saurabh

Giuseppe Larosa Mon, 12/14/2009 - 03:27
User Badges:
  • Super Silver, 17500 points or more
  • Hall of Fame,

    Founding Member

Hello Rc.Castillo,


the trunking protocol must match on both  ends of a single link.



Sw1 ---- ISL ---- Sw2 ---- dot1q---- AP


this can work but both ends of second link has to be configured for 802.1Q.

SW2 can perform all the necessary conversions between the two protocol formats without any additional config.




int type x/y

desc versus AP

switchport trunk enc dot1q

switchport mode trunk

switchport trunk allowed vlan 10,20,30


But Sw2 port towards AP should have:

switchport trunk enc dot1q


if the switchport mode is desirable and the access point is Cisco it may work also with

switchport mode desirable because they might be able to negotiate with DTP the trunk status and the trunking protocol.


But it is more safe to configure explicitly


Hope to help

Giuseppe

Actions

This Discussion