02-17-2012 12:42 AM - edited 03-17-2019 10:50 PM
Hi,
i´ve got some questions on nHD with 8510 MCU Version 4.3:
2. What happens, if set the MCU to nHD and a HD-Endpoint dials in?
thanks
Tino
Solved! Go to Solution.
02-17-2012 07:40 AM
Hi Tino!
1) I just tested it, with 60 licenses on the 8510 you get either 60 sd port or 80 nHD, so 80 is the limit. Not tested but assume that clustering is also not possible.
So the intention for me looks more that you can get more out of your purchased licenses (guess for us it can be
nice for some more boradcast style announcements or desktop/mobile endpoints) and not increase port >80.
2) you just dont get more resolution, example:
Movi (4:3 integrated cam):
Tx: CIF, H.264, 704k, AAC-LD
Rx: CIF, H.264, 768k, AAC-LD
c20:
Tx: 512 x 288, H.264, 2.00M, AAC-LD
Rx: 640 x 360, H.264, 2.00M, AAC-LD
Please remember to rate helpful responses and identify
02-17-2012 07:48 AM
And here an extract of the online help:
And from the online help:
This topic only applies to the MCU 4500 Series and the MCU MSE 8510.
The MCU has following media port modes and capacities:
Media port mode | Capacity |
---|---|
nHD | Up to w360p at 30fps. |
SD | Up to w448p at 30fps. |
HD | Up to 720p at 30fps or w448p at 60fps. |
HD+ | Up to 1080p at 30fps (asymmetric), or 720p at 60fps, however, endpoints will only be allowed to send 720p at 30fps or w448p at 60fps. The MCU will send higher resolutions by using multi-pane layouts. |
Full HD | Up to 1080p at 30fps (symmetric), or 720p at 60fps. |
For information about the number of ports available on the different models of MCU, refer to MCU port matrix.
On the MCU MSE 8510, each Full HD and HD+ participant requires four media port licenses. Each HD participant requires two media port licenses. Each SD participant requires only one media port license. Therefore, to achieve the full capacity in Full HD mode you need to allocate 60 port licenses to the blade, and for HD+ mode 80 media port licenses. To achieve full capacity in HD mode you need to allocate a total of 40 media port licenses to the blade. To achieve the full capacity in SD mode you need to allocate a total of 80 media port licenses to the blade. nHD mode requires 40 licenses (i.e. each port consumes 0.5 of a license). For information on how to allocate further ports to your blade, see the Supervisor online help.
To change the media port capacity mode go to Settings > Media ports.
After enabling a mode, you must restart the MCU for changes to take effect.
The selected option section shows you how many ports are available for each type of connection in the selected mode. The number of available ports will change when you switch between modes in the drop down menu. This is useful as it allows you to see the port availability before you enable either mode and restart the MCU.
Field | Field description |
---|---|
Media port mode | The required media port capacity. Choose from Full HD, HD+, HD, SD or nHD. |
Full high definition video ports | The number of 1080p30 (symmetric) video ports available. Note: This is to transmit and receive at this resolution. |
High definition plus video ports | The number of 1080p30 (asymmetric) video ports available. Note: This is to transmit at this resolution only. |
High definition video ports | The number of 720p30 video ports available. |
Standard definition video ports | Only available on the MCU 4501. |
nHD video ports | MCU MSE 8510 only, the number of standard definition video ports available. |
Dedicated streaming and content ports | The number of dedicated streaming and content ports available. Where streaming and content ports are provided, when streaming and content ports are used up, video ports will not be allocated to streaming viewers or providers of content. Where there are no streaming and content ports, conferences with streaming viewers and conferences with content will use available video ports. |
Additional audio ports | The number of audio-only ports available. Each audio port can be used by one voice-only participant in a video conference. When audio-only ports are unavailable, voice-only participants will use available video ports. On the MCU MSE 8510, if Standard definition mode is selected, this value will always appear as zero. |
Please remember to rate helpful responses and identify
02-18-2012 06:29 AM
1) when I clicked on send it also catched my eye, I can tell you the MSE8510 can be configured in the SD mode, so it looks like a glitch in the documentation
2) it is a generic MCU setting not not something on a per call base, also all ports on a mcu are set
to the same mode, so you can not have 10FullHD and 40nHD on the same MCU (thugh I would like it)
If you want different settings you would need different blades, like one in SD and one in FullHD.
The tables in the second message I posted here show you what you get on a blade if you set a specitic mode.
A cluster slave blade alwas follows the setting of the cluster master. Only HD modes work for clustering,
(nHD is not an HD mode), 3 blades can be clustered.
If you set the blade to FullHD (60 sd-port licenses needed for 15 FullHD ports)
you can only connect 15 clients, even if all are only using w360p
Dont forget if you would think of switching from 15FullHD to 80nHD ports that you would
also need proper call licenses on the VCS.
3) See above, so: No
Please remember to rate helpful responses and identify
02-17-2012 07:40 AM
Hi Tino!
1) I just tested it, with 60 licenses on the 8510 you get either 60 sd port or 80 nHD, so 80 is the limit. Not tested but assume that clustering is also not possible.
So the intention for me looks more that you can get more out of your purchased licenses (guess for us it can be
nice for some more boradcast style announcements or desktop/mobile endpoints) and not increase port >80.
2) you just dont get more resolution, example:
Movi (4:3 integrated cam):
Tx: CIF, H.264, 704k, AAC-LD
Rx: CIF, H.264, 768k, AAC-LD
c20:
Tx: 512 x 288, H.264, 2.00M, AAC-LD
Rx: 640 x 360, H.264, 2.00M, AAC-LD
Please remember to rate helpful responses and identify
02-04-2016 11:25 AM
Is there any documentation on the difference between HD/HD+/FullHD and how this relates to your content mode on the codian e.g. IF you have content set to Hybrid in HD mode your content will be stuck at 10FPS with Cisco endpoints that are fully capabile of 720p30fps for both TX/RX of video streams and H.239 or BFCP. The only work around i've been able to figure out is having to set the port modes to FullHD to consistently get content to work at 720p30fps on Tx/Rx.
I'd imagine Hybrid mode is the preferred method of content since it has the best of Transcoding and Passthrough modes enabled potentially. Getting this to work in practice is another thing all together. Endpoints (c series/SX/MX) units that are full H.264 capable will drop down to H.263++ transmission of H.239/BFCP content in this mode and send 10fps content. This is in a homogeneous Cisco end to end environment.
I have no idea why the caps exchange on these cisco devices would ever use H.263++ instead of H.264 but its easily reproducible. TAC has no idea and says working as designed. They also don't see to understand the differences in video compression and why you do NOT want to use H.263 compression anymore.
I suspect its a bug on the codian as the endpoints in point-to-point don't exhibit this type of behavior-- but I keep getting told i need to move to TPS firmware on the codian instead of isolating the potential bug. The documentation and port matrix help file do not help on this. This really reminds me of Polycom's crappy mix and match ports on the MGC where the various cards didn't match capabilities and you were forced to buy extra blades...
MattM
02-17-2012 07:47 AM
And maybe also interesting for those who wonder about the port capabilities:
Media port mode | FullHD |
Selected option | |
Full high definition video ports | 15 |
High definition plus video ports | 0 |
High definition video ports | 0 |
Standard definition video ports | 0 |
nHD video ports | 0 |
Dedicated streaming and content ports | 0 |
Additional audio ports | 15 |
Media port mode | HD+ |
Selected option | |
Full high definition video ports | 0 |
High definition plus video ports | 20 |
High definition video ports | 0 |
Standard definition video ports | 0 |
nHD video ports | 0 |
Dedicated streaming and content ports | 0 |
Additional audio ports | 20 |
Media port mode | HD |
Selected option | |
Full high definition video ports | 0 |
High definition plus video ports | 0 |
High definition video ports | 20 |
Standard definition video ports | 0 |
nHD video ports | 0 |
Dedicated streaming and content ports | 20 |
Additional audio ports | 20 |
Media port mode | SD |
Selected option | |
Full high definition video ports | 0 |
High definition plus video ports | 0 |
High definition video ports | 0 |
Standard definition video ports | 80 |
nHD video ports | 0 |
Dedicated streaming and content ports | 0 |
Additional audio ports | 0 |
Media port mode | nHD |
Selected option | |
Full high definition video ports | 0 |
High definition plus video ports | 0 |
High definition video ports | 0 |
Standard definition video ports | 0 |
nHD video ports | 80 |
Dedicated streaming and content ports | 0 |
Additional audio ports | 0 |
Please remember to rate helpful responses and identify
02-17-2012 07:48 AM
And here an extract of the online help:
And from the online help:
This topic only applies to the MCU 4500 Series and the MCU MSE 8510.
The MCU has following media port modes and capacities:
Media port mode | Capacity |
---|---|
nHD | Up to w360p at 30fps. |
SD | Up to w448p at 30fps. |
HD | Up to 720p at 30fps or w448p at 60fps. |
HD+ | Up to 1080p at 30fps (asymmetric), or 720p at 60fps, however, endpoints will only be allowed to send 720p at 30fps or w448p at 60fps. The MCU will send higher resolutions by using multi-pane layouts. |
Full HD | Up to 1080p at 30fps (symmetric), or 720p at 60fps. |
For information about the number of ports available on the different models of MCU, refer to MCU port matrix.
On the MCU MSE 8510, each Full HD and HD+ participant requires four media port licenses. Each HD participant requires two media port licenses. Each SD participant requires only one media port license. Therefore, to achieve the full capacity in Full HD mode you need to allocate 60 port licenses to the blade, and for HD+ mode 80 media port licenses. To achieve full capacity in HD mode you need to allocate a total of 40 media port licenses to the blade. To achieve the full capacity in SD mode you need to allocate a total of 80 media port licenses to the blade. nHD mode requires 40 licenses (i.e. each port consumes 0.5 of a license). For information on how to allocate further ports to your blade, see the Supervisor online help.
To change the media port capacity mode go to Settings > Media ports.
After enabling a mode, you must restart the MCU for changes to take effect.
The selected option section shows you how many ports are available for each type of connection in the selected mode. The number of available ports will change when you switch between modes in the drop down menu. This is useful as it allows you to see the port availability before you enable either mode and restart the MCU.
Field | Field description |
---|---|
Media port mode | The required media port capacity. Choose from Full HD, HD+, HD, SD or nHD. |
Full high definition video ports | The number of 1080p30 (symmetric) video ports available. Note: This is to transmit and receive at this resolution. |
High definition plus video ports | The number of 1080p30 (asymmetric) video ports available. Note: This is to transmit at this resolution only. |
High definition video ports | The number of 720p30 video ports available. |
Standard definition video ports | Only available on the MCU 4501. |
nHD video ports | MCU MSE 8510 only, the number of standard definition video ports available. |
Dedicated streaming and content ports | The number of dedicated streaming and content ports available. Where streaming and content ports are provided, when streaming and content ports are used up, video ports will not be allocated to streaming viewers or providers of content. Where there are no streaming and content ports, conferences with streaming viewers and conferences with content will use available video ports. |
Additional audio ports | The number of audio-only ports available. Each audio port can be used by one voice-only participant in a video conference. When audio-only ports are unavailable, voice-only participants will use available video ports. On the MCU MSE 8510, if Standard definition mode is selected, this value will always appear as zero. |
Please remember to rate helpful responses and identify
02-17-2012 09:31 AM
Hi Martin,
thank you for the very detailed answer. Questions on this:
Thank you!
greetings
Tino
02-18-2012 06:29 AM
1) when I clicked on send it also catched my eye, I can tell you the MSE8510 can be configured in the SD mode, so it looks like a glitch in the documentation
2) it is a generic MCU setting not not something on a per call base, also all ports on a mcu are set
to the same mode, so you can not have 10FullHD and 40nHD on the same MCU (thugh I would like it)
If you want different settings you would need different blades, like one in SD and one in FullHD.
The tables in the second message I posted here show you what you get on a blade if you set a specitic mode.
A cluster slave blade alwas follows the setting of the cluster master. Only HD modes work for clustering,
(nHD is not an HD mode), 3 blades can be clustered.
If you set the blade to FullHD (60 sd-port licenses needed for 15 FullHD ports)
you can only connect 15 clients, even if all are only using w360p
Dont forget if you would think of switching from 15FullHD to 80nHD ports that you would
also need proper call licenses on the VCS.
3) See above, so: No
Please remember to rate helpful responses and identify
02-18-2012 06:43 AM
Martin,
thank you for clearifying this. If I´m able to set the media mode to sd or nHD on 8510 I´m clear on this.
cheers
Tino
02-18-2012 07:23 AM
Yes, you can!
Thx for voting and setting the thread to answered! +5
Please remember to rate helpful responses and identify
02-28-2012 07:36 AM
Hi Martin,
could you please tell me where in the CCO I can find the online help you've pasted in these your latest replies? I assume it's the ver.4_3 online help and so far I only managed to track down the 4_2 one.
thanks a lot,
francesco
02-28-2012 11:39 AM
Its from the "real online" online help which is "hosted" on the mcu itself:
http(s)://<4.3MCUaddress>/help_top_level.html
Please remember to rate helpful responses and identify
Discover and save your favorite ideas. Come back to expert answers, step-by-step guides, recent topics, and more.
New here? Get started with these tips. How to use Community New member guide