Cisco Support Community
cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
Announcements

Welcome to Cisco Support Community. We would love to have your feedback.

For an introduction to the new site, click here. If you'd prefer to explore, try our test area to get started. And see here for current known issues.

New Member

Zone Based Firewall dropping SYN from inside to DMVPN? (config attached)

Hi all,

I'm having a problem with ZBFW appearing to cause retransmits when connecting from an inside host to a host on the remote side of the DMVPN.  ICMP appears to work fine, but RDP ends up with two sessions: one established and one half-open.  When the half-open session times out, the connection dies.

What's interesting is that initiating a connection from a DMVPN host to an internal host, the connection gets established and I can stay connected all day with no problem.  The router in question is a 7206vxr running 15.1(4)M7, and it serves as an internet edge router.  All routes are present (EIGRP over DMVPN) and internet access is fine.

If I move the tunnel interfaces into the LAN security zone, no problem.  Traffic flows from inside to outside.  It's just when I have them into a separate zone, things get strange.  I'm posting a sanitized config in case there's some glaring issue I've missed.

Output from 'sh policy-map type inspect zone-pair LAN-to-DMVPN sessions' when initiating an RDP session:

policy exists on zp LAN-to-DMVPN

Zone-pair: LAN-to-DMVPN

  Service-policy inspect : LAN-to-DMVPN

    Class-map: LAN-to-DMVPN (match-all)

      Match: access-group name LAN-to-DMVPN

   Inspect

      Number of Established Sessions = 1

      Established Sessions

        Session 68AFD3A0 (192.168.77.160:3623)=>(172.23.2.13:3389) tcp SIS_OPEN/TCP_ESTAB

          Created 00:00:09, Last heard 00:00:09

          Bytes sent (initiator:responder) [0:0]

      Number of Half-open Sessions = 1

      Half-open Sessions

        Session 68B027A0 (192.168.77.160:3623)=>(172.23.2.13:3389) tcp SIS_OPENING/TCP_SYNSENT

          Created 00:00:09, Last heard 00:00:09

          Bytes sent (initiator:responder) [0:0]

    Class-map: class-default (match-any)

      Match: any

      Drop

        0 packets, 0 bytes

Note the same source and destination pairs with different session IDs.

Now, when I connect from DMVPN to LAN via RDP:

policy exists on zp DMVPN-to-LAN

Zone-pair: DMVPN-to-LAN

  Service-policy inspect : DMVPN-to-LAN

    Class-map: DMVPN-to-LAN (match-all)

      Match: access-group name DMVPN-to-LAN

   Inspect

      Number of Established Sessions = 1

      Established Sessions

        Session 68B051A0 (172.23.2.13:55622)=>(192.168.77.160:3389) tcp SIS_OPEN/TCP_ESTAB

          Created 01:21:17, Last heard 00:00:00

          Bytes sent (initiator:responder) [585503:10830828]

    Class-map: class-default (match-any)

      Match: any

      Drop

        2 packets, 40 bytes

Also note that this connection has been up for over an hour, and it does _not_ create the half-open session when the initial connect takes place.

Any ideas?

Thanks!

-P

5 REPLIES

Re: Zone Based Firewall dropping SYN from inside to DMVPN? (conf

Hello, Palmer.

ZBFW looks good; the only thing I could suggest to try is:

- rewrite ACL DMVPN-to-LAN without service "object-group RDP+SSH+ICMP" - write with "tcp ... eq 22/3389" stetements.

- or try to remove DMVPN to LAN pair (just to test).

New Member

Zone Based Firewall dropping SYN from inside to DMVPN? (config a

Thanks Mikhailovsky,

I tested with the change to the ACL, but no luck.  There isn't a problem from the DMVPN-to-LAN side - this works as expected, and the ACL shows hits either way it's configured.

The problem persists with LAN-to-DMVPN - one established and one half-open, and the connection dies when the half-open resets due to not receiving ACK SYN (but the established connection obviously completed 3-way handshake) - it's like something in the firewall config is causing the initial SYN to be retransmitted.

I've also tried with 15.2(4)M5 with no luck.  Any other ideas?

Thanks!

-P

Re: Zone Based Firewall dropping SYN from inside to DMVPN? (conf

Hello, Palmer.

Try to remove DMVPN to LAN pair (just to test) - I suspect it could cause (on backtrack SYN) this weird session when TCP originated from LAN!

New Member

Re: Zone Based Firewall dropping SYN from inside to DMVPN? (conf

Mikhailovsky,

Still no dice.  Didn't think it would affect the return traffic, but gave it a shot anyway.  It's just baffling that ZBF is working as expected from DMVPN to LAN but the LAN to DMVPN traffic gets screwy.  It's not just on RDP sessions, either - any interactive session I attempt to open dies out.  I'm starting to wonder if it's got to do with NAT - that's the only difference in ingress traffic from the LAN side.  I can probably simplify it by replacing the route-map with an ACL - there were initially two ISPs terminating on the router so the route-map was larger to identify different traffic sources

In the meantime - anything else you can think of?  Anyone?

Thanks!

-P

New Member

Re: Zone Based Firewall dropping SYN from inside to DMVPN? (conf

Update:
I configured this on an 1811W running IOS 15(1)4 M7 and all was well. Must have been a problem with the hardware. Marking thus as answered - thanks for the replies.

-P

Sent from Cisco Technical Support iPad App

326
Views
2
Helpful
5
Replies