Cisco Support Community
cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
Announcements

Welcome to Cisco Support Community. We would love to have your feedback.

For an introduction to the new site, click here. If you'd prefer to explore, try our test area to get started. And see here for current known issues.

New Member

Wireless adapters

Anyone want to chime in on using aironet versus Linksys wireless adapters connecting to an Aironet 1231G AP? The cost difference is significant between the two. The application does not require significant bandwidth for this installation.

Thanks in advance

8 REPLIES

Re: Wireless adapters

You have to ask yourself a couple of questions, in order to find the appropriate one for your needs:

What use are you intend to have?

What security do you need on your network? For example, WPA2? LEAP?

What frequencies will you use with your AP?

What linksys card exactly are you comparing it with?

You say 1000 feet, is that outdoor, indoor? Thick walls, open space? Manufacture environment with a lot of interference?

There is no really black or white answer, it depends on the features you do want from the cards and the environment you will use them.

Once you have answers to those questions you can compare the technical specs of the cards and see if they respond to your needs.

I do suggest to have at least one aironet card so you can do the wireless survey in WCS and have a very accurate representation of your coverage on the WCS map.

New Member

Re: Wireless adapters

Answers to your questions:

Telnet and email

WPA

Not sure, we typically go with the default settings on Cisco AP's

Linksys WMP54G

Indoor in a Manufacturing environment with heavy machinery and open spaces

Thanks

Re: Wireless adapters

WPA is supported by both cards

Coverage should be ok with both cards, not a big difference.

I suggest you, if you decide to go with the linksys cards, to at least get 1 cisco card for the site survey on WCS, it may be something that will come very useful later on, when you start using network monitoring and management for your wireless cloud.

Re: Wireless adapters

You may want to think about support problems. Given your usage model, support for the cards if not likely to be a big problem, however, calling Linksys for support will be a pain. If you have all your Cisco gear on a support contract, then if you have a problem specific to the Cisco WLAN cards, it will be easy to get support.

If you're going to make a major purchase, I would strongly recommend that you investigate 802.11n-capable cards. You may not have 802.11n access points, but you might in the future. If you think you're going to have to keep supporting the wireless cards for a few years, I'd recommend going with an 802.11n card (Linksys is good).

Re: Wireless adapters

I would make sure roaming is what you want. I have tested some of the linksys cards myself and they were not ideal for roaming. These cards are designed for soho enviroments not enterprise.

__________________________________________________________________________________________ "Satisfaction does not come from knowing the solution, it comes from knowing why." - Rosalind Franklin ___________________________________________________________

Re: Wireless adapters

Linksys cards by their nature were designed for consumer(home) use and are parent sticky. They were designed to attach to your linksys router or AP and not your neighbors. They roam horribly and often will only leave the last AP associated with only after it is no longer seen. In a manufacturing facility this will kill you. Also, in a manufacturing facility multipath is almost always an issue. MiMO based APs are the best to use here along with .11n client adapters.

New Member

Re: Wireless adapters

Thanks to everyone who responded. 98% of the PC's that will require wireless access will be desktop PC's and will not be mobile. I realize that Linksys is more for home use but they are almost 4 times less expensive than the Aironet cards. Any mobile devices will use Aironet cards.

Re: Wireless adapters

For desktops, please get a card that has some way of mounting the antenna somewhere besides the back of the PC. Too often we get complaints of poor wireless speeds on desktops, only to discover that the desktop is tucked into a corner under a metal desk where it's a bit hard to get good wireless coverage.

If you have the opportunity to pilot, then buy just a few cards and pilot them before you make a large investment in a particular card.

152
Views
0
Helpful
8
Replies