Cisco Support Community
cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
Announcements

Welcome to Cisco Support Community. We would love to have your feedback.

For an introduction to the new site, click here. And see here for current known issues.

New Member

Extending same VLAN across multiple distributions

Hi

Just wondering what the current thoughts are on the following common problem  .......

  • Have 3 x L3 distribution pairs (#1, 2 and 3) with a number of fully redundant L2 access switches off each
  • Distributions are connected via a L2 core
  • VLAN X is root/root secondary on Distribution Pair 1. Need to extend the same VLAN X to L2 access switches hanging off Distribution Pair 2 and 3.
  • Single Mode fiber between distributions. Multimode fiber between access and distribution.

Do I simply connect a fiber from Distribution Pair 1 to both Distribution Pair 2 and 3 and extend down to access via trunk? This is obviously possible but not allowing for a clear demarcation and could cause instability from one network to extend to another.

Do I play it safe and put in a L2 aggregation switch (with fiber ports) beside each of Distributions 2 and 3 and in turn have dedicated (parallel) access switches for that VLAN X. This is a waste but would probably less of a risk than the first option.

Other options?

Thanks

Patrick 

Everyone's tags (4)
2 REPLIES
New Member

Extending same VLAN across multiple distributions

Patrick,

- do you have VTP running on the network?

- are there any overlapping VLAN's between distribution sites?

- what's the distance between distribution sites? Do you expect high latency?

- what's the diameter of the switched network?

Assuming no VTP, no overlap, small distance/low-latency between sites, relatively small # of hops between hosts that need to talk ...

You can safely connect each of the distribution sites together for VLAN X. You should manually prune all VLAN's except VLAN X on the new distribution trunks. Use "switchport trunk allowed vlan X".

hth,

Dan

New Member

Extending same VLAN across multiple distributions

This is a pretty tough one. There might be some options in Nexus that would let you do it.

Basically, if it's layer 3 between switches, you're pretty screwed.

You COULD go to a hybrid layer 3 model, where you trunk vlans across all of the switches as suggested above, and move the L3 IP configuration from the interface on the switch to a SVI, then trunk that SVI between switches to keep the layer 3 routing working. So basically you could have layer 3 connectivity using the IP addresses on trunked vlan Y, and then add vlans X and Z to the trunk to have the same layer 2 vlan in all 3 areas.

Andy

781
Views
0
Helpful
2
Replies