Cisco Support Community
cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
New Member

HSRP vs GLBP

Regarding GLBP - after using both HSRP & GLBP I wonder one one might choose HSRP over GLBP ?

Would you comment please ?

5 REPLIES
New Member

Re: HSRP vs GLBP

HSRP is preferable when you use the second link solely as backup link. A standard situation would be an ISDN dial-up backup link, when you want the backup only to be used when the primary fails. If you use GLBP in such a configuration, ISDN will be up continously, and generate costs. Other instances where HSRP is preferable would be when your backup link has less bandwidth or higher latency. GLBP is unaware of possible performance issues with the backup link, and you can not control which traffic will be sent over the backup.

- Thomas

New Member

Re: HSRP vs GLBP

Understood - thanks Thomas

Silver

Re: HSRP vs GLBP

GLBP is a true load balancing protocol. With HSRP in order to load balance across two routers you need to create two HSRP groups. GLBP provides load balancing wihtout the need to configure separate primary / standby groups.

GLBP selects an AVG (active virtual GW) and load balances using round-robin, weigthed or host dependent.

If there is no need for load balancing across gateways then HSRP is fine. Also GLBP requires minimal IOS requirements, that some organizations do not have deployed. So HSRP is supported in lower IOS revisons. Some orgs do not need or want to upgrade IOS.

Super Bronze

Re: HSRP vs GLBP

Robert's mention of load balancing across two routers using two HSRP groups, or MHSRP, can be an example of an instance where you'll want to use HSRP rather than GLBP. GLBP splits traffic, I believe, by source MAC. So if lots of traffic is being souced by one or only one device, using a single MAC, all its traffic will all take the same gateway. If you can point the source at two routers each with their own HSRP addresses (with standby on the other), you may better load balance the traffic to the gateway routers.

New Member

Re: HSRP vs GLBP

Interesting perspectives - thanks gentlemen.

347
Views
1
Helpful
5
Replies
CreatePlease to create content