Cisco Support Community
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Welcome to Cisco Support Community. We would love to have your feedback.

For an introduction to the new site, click here. If you'd prefer to explore, try our test area to get started. And see here for current known issues.

New Member

IDF question

We have a couple of 6509's that are setup for load-balancing/failover...both have identical vlans with one being a standby and the primary. We're running IEGRP for routing.

My question is, we have a 3750 which all the workstations plug in it generally recommended to set up trunks from the 3750 to the 6509s and have the 6509s be the gateway, or is it better to set up layer 3 links, have the 3750 be the gateway and let EIGRP make all the routing decisions to the 6509s?

  • LAN Switching and Routing

Accepted Solutions

Re: IDF question

My pleasure...glad I can help.


Re: IDF question


The trend these days is to deploy a routed access layer, if the application permits, of course. The reasons for doing so are primarily:

1. To decrease convergenece time in the event of an outage, since routing protocols do converge faster than STP.

2. Minimize the chance of suffering a layer 2 loop, since the switched environemnt will be greatly reduced in size. This is called L3 isolation

3. Traffic load banlancing across equal cost multiple paths -- what Cisco refers to as ECMP.

If you go with the routed access layer design, you must know that you cannot span the user VLANs across the distro/core layer. The VLAN will be confined to the local access switch. If all the users terminate their connections on the same switch, then this could be the way to go.

If you are deploying a collapsed core, i would definitely go with the routed access design.

A switched access layer with L2 trunks uplinked to a routed distro layer does provide more scalabiliaty, especially in the data Center (server farm). But I see your concern is with the campus/user environment.

Feel free to post more concerns/questions. Hope my ramblings helped.


New Member

Re: IDF question

Thanks alot Victor, I appreciate the response and suggestions. I kind of had the same thoughts, but it really helps to have someone confirm it. :)

Thanks again



Re: IDF question

My pleasure...glad I can help.