Cisco Support Community
cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
Announcements

Welcome to Cisco Support Community. We would love to have your feedback.

For an introduction to the new site, click here. And see here for current known issues.

New Member

l3 MPLS or VPLS

Hi,

To connect 10 sites to head office whcih technology would be better VPLS or MPLS? I would add more sites later on and it should have voice, video and critical application qos support. I know MPLS is better than VPLS in some respect. But VPSL comes into play where its simple network VPN deployment. I am looking for suggestion about VPLS/MPLS deployment scenario and their advantages and disadvantages.

regards,

arman

3 REPLIES
VIP Super Bronze

Re: l3 MPLS or VPLS

Hi Arman,

I would go with L3 MPLS/VPN.  In a layer 3 VPN troubleshooting is a lot easier, because the PE has a point-to-point L3 interface with the CE.  Therefore, if there is any issue,  you can easily use tools like trace route and ping to troubleshot the interfaces  In a layer-2 environment, all sites appear to be in the same LAN even though they traverse the service provider's backbone.  Also since VPLS is deployed in networks in a point-to-multipoint fashion, the packet originating from a CE device can be broadcast to all the PE routers participating in a VPLS routing instance.

HTH

Reza

New Member

Re: l3 MPLS or VPLS

You can have point to point vlan using VPLS as well. Am I right?

Arman

New Member

Re: l3 MPLS or VPLS

I believe it all comes down to what you want to achieve. MPLS VPNs and VPLS are all MPLS apps and each has a unique role. VPLS is to achieve broadcast capability at Layer 2 while MPLS VPNs are at Layer 3. These are two disparate technologies and trying to decide which one to use is like comparing bread and stone.  Choose which meets your needs. MPLS VPNs benefit the provider while VPLS enables the Customers to transparently emulate a Layer 2 protocol across the service provider MPLS backbone. STP, VTP, etc can all operate normally as within a local VLAN or switched domain.

Should require point-to-point, go in or AToM or L2TPv3

928
Views
0
Helpful
3
Replies
CreatePlease to create content