Cisco Support Community
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Welcome to Cisco Support Community. We would love to have your feedback.

For an introduction to the new site, click here. And see here for current known issues.

New Member

Trunking Protocol?

Which is better isl or dot1.q? I have 4 vlans setup on a rather small network.

New Member

Re: Trunking Protocol?

ISL is Cisco specific, 802.1q is open so you will be able to use it with different vendors switches as well.

With ISL, traffic from all VLANs is tagged whereas with 802.1q the native VLAN is untagged. This untagged traffic can lead to problems if all switches are not configured to use the same native VLAN.

It used to be that ISL could be used with PVST and 802.1q couldn't. This is no longer a restriction.

Personally, as long as you are prepared to take the care with the native VLANs, I would say to go with 802.1q - in that way if further switches from other manufacturers are added at any time you will be OK. There are also Cisco switches that are unable to run ISL, so again 802.1q is the only option if you have one of those.

CreatePlease login to create content