Cisco Support Community
cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
Announcements

Welcome to Cisco Support Community. We would love to have your feedback.

For an introduction to the new site, click here. If you'd prefer to explore, try our test area to get started. And see here for current known issues.

New Member

VPN Concentrator vs IOS

Dear all,

are there any documents describing the pros and cons of each choice..?

3 REPLIES
Bronze

Re: VPN Concentrator vs IOS

Hi,

none that I'm aware of, rule of thumb is that, when you have many L2Ls that needed to be configured and less number of vpn client users, you go for ios, otherwise if you have a large users base for remote access VPNs, and low # of L2Ls, then VPN3k is better.

Anyhow, there is no replacement of IOS routing capability on VPN3K, so routing could also be a major determining factor in choosing IOS.

best of luck.

Thx

Afaq

New Member

Re: VPN Concentrator vs IOS

I can give some of the pros & cons I have encountered. IOS vpns are fine if you have a small amount of users. I say this becuase when you bought you router if you did not plan for this then you will really burden your router. If you have the memory and the encryption modules and vpn accelerator board then you should be fine. Advantage; move in cost is low for a small amout of users. One box to maintain and configure.Has the ability to pass muntiple protocols. Cons;high move in cost for large amount of users. VPN tunnels can distract the router forom it primary task, routing. Difficult to set up failover or load balancing.

VPN concentrators are great if you have a large amount of users. They are dedicated boxes for this task. You can add encryption modules and you can set up a pair to be redundant or load balance.Advantages; dedicated appliance for terminating vpn tunnels. Better performance. Redunancy and load balancing. Cons; very high move in cost for small amount of users. Time required to learn and correctly deploy. will only pass ip traffic.

As with both solutions you need to determine the client software you will use and the protocols you need to use. If you have less than 50 users cost is an issue and only need to use ip only and don't need any encryption then use pptp on a router packed with memory and has a fast processor, 2651 or 3640 for example. If you have more than 50 and need encryption get a 3015, if you have more than 100 then get a 3030 with at least 1 sep card.

Hope this helps

New Member

Re: VPN Concentrator vs IOS

I'll go out on a limb and simplify.

End user vpn: Appropriately sized concentrator

"Site to Site" vpn: Appropriately sized IOS router

89
Views
13
Helpful
3
Replies